This blog references an older version of Inside the Mind of Hacker. Check out this blog to see the newest version of the report.

Every year when Bugcrowd’s flagship report, Inside the Mind of a Hacker, comes out, readers get the newest data and trends around the hacker community–from demographics to motivations. In the 2023 edition, we surprised readers with a special section all about generative AI. For so long, AI felt like a looming storm cloud–distant yet ominous. But almost overnight, generative AI became accessible to the masses. The internet is filled with fear-mongering articles covering the terrifying consequences AI could have on cybersecurity, but in Inside the Mind of a Hacker, we wanted to talk about some of the cool ways hackers are using AI to make the world a safer place. Fast rollout of advanced AI and large generative AI systems is increasing corporate attack risks. Security leaders must address these new dangers.

We compiled an infographic of some of the biggest generative AI findings, which you can check out below. Here are five of the most surprising findings:

1. 94% of hackers already use AI or plan to start using it in the future to help them ethically hack

The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into cybersecurity practices is becoming increasingly prevalent, with a striking 94% of hackers either currently leveraging AI technologies or planning to incorporate them in the near future to assist with ethical hacking. This trend underscores the transformative potential of AI in identifying vulnerabilities more efficiently and effectively. Large language models (LLMs), a subset of AI, play a crucial role in this evolution by enabling hackers to automate complex tasks, analyze vast amounts of data rapidly, and predict potential security threats. Hackers use machine learning to better simulate cyberattacks. They keep improving their methods, which helps make cybersecurity stronger. 

Why it matters for security teams:

  • Empower security professionals and red-blue security teams to run AI-assisted reconnaissance sooner during AI projects and AI initiatives.
  • Build rapid incident response playbooks that assume adversaries leverage AI hacking to discover zero-day attacks faster.

Glossary of terms for generative AI hacking:

  • Artificial Intelligence (AI): Leveraged to identify vulnerabilities and automate tasks in ethical hacking.
  • Large Language Models (LLMs): Essential for processing and analyzing large datasets in cybersecurity.
  • Machine Learning: Enables continuous improvement of threat simulation and defensive strategies.
  • Ethical Hacking: The proactive use of hacking techniques to strengthen security protocols.
  • Cybersecurity: Enhanced through AI by predicting threats and automating responses.

2. 72% of hackers do not believe AI will ever replicate the human creativity of hackers

The integration of artificial intelligence into cybersecurity has sparked extensive debate, particularly regarding its ability to mimic the creativity of human hackers. Notably, 72% of hackers maintain a skeptical view, expressing disbelief that AI could ever fully replicate the instinctual and creative intricacies inherent in human-led cyber attacks. Hackers pair classic social engineering tactics, ranging from emotionally charged spear-phishing and vibe hacking on social media to dumpster-diving intel, with AI tools that accelerate campaign scale. It’s this capacity for creative problem-solving and out-of-the-box thinking that many believe AI cannot emulate. The nuanced and adaptable nature of human intelligence, particularly when it comes to manipulating various attack vectors, remains a hallmark of human ingenuity in the cyber realm. Despite AI’s advancements, these hackers argue that creativity and intuition are facets of cybersecurity where humans still have the upper hand.

  • 72% of hackers doubt AI’s ability to replicate human creativity in hacking.
  • Human hackers are known for their unique, instinctual creativity that contributes to cyber attacks.
  • Threat actors often exploit creative strategies that leverage a deep understanding of human behavior.
  • Phishing attacks crafted by humans are tailored and adaptive, challenging for AI to replicate effectively.
  • Human hackers manipulate attack vectors with nuanced intelligence and adaptability.
  • AI’s advancements in cybersecurity still fall short where human intuition and creativity dominate.
  • The debate continues on whether AI can evolve to fully match human-led cyber attack strategies.

3. 91% of hackers believe that AI technologies have increased the value of hacking or will increase its value in the future

In a fast-changing digital world, AI and cybersecurity meet in ways that affect both defenders and attackers deeply. A striking 91% of hackers believe that AI technologies have either already increased the value of hacking or will do so in the future, highlighting a critical paradigm shift. Using generative AI in cybersecurity brings both chances and problems. Generative AI can improve security by finding weak spots and automating responses. But it also gives bad actors smart tools to increase their attacks. By leveraging machine learning models and generative adversarial networks, hackers can create convincing phishing scams, launch automated attacks, and exploit existing security gaps with unprecedented precision and speed. AI-driven exploit kits now ship with on-the-fly polymorphic malware builders, cutting custom malware development cycles from days to minutes and super-charging phishing campaigns that target unpatched environments. This changing threat needs strong AI risk management plans. These protect sensitive data and systems from advanced cyber threats. 

  • Over 90% of hackers anticipate AI will elevate the value of hacking efforts.
  • Generative AI can improve cybersecurity but also enhance malicious activity.
  • Machine learning models and generative adversarial networks are tools for both security enhancement and exploitation.
  • Robust AI risk management frameworks are essential to counteract advanced cyber threats.
  • The intersection of AI and cybersecurity presents significant challenges and opportunities for defense strategies.

4. 98% of hackers using generative AI for security research use ChatGPT

This powerful tool is reshaping the way malicious scripting and vulnerability research are conducted. By employing AI-generated content, hackers can efficiently automate and optimize processes that were traditionally time-consuming. ChatGPT helps analyze security data. It lets hackers find system weak spots more easily. Furthermore, its capabilities extend to enhancing security event and incident management processes, making it a double-edged sword in the cybersecurity domain. AI helps real security research and defense. But bad use of AI needs more awareness and action from cybersecurity experts. 

  • Malicious Scripting: Hackers use ChatGPT to automate the generation of scripts designed to exploit system vulnerabilities, including crafting nuanced prompts that bypass content filters and auto-generate payloads for AI security tool testing and blue-team incident response drills. 
  • Vulnerability Research: By analyzing patterns and input data, ChatGPT assists in identifying weak points in security systems.
  • Security Data: The AI’s capability to process large volumes of security data helps hackers pinpoint areas of interest faster.
  • AI-Generated Content: ChatGPT’s generative abilities are harnessed to craft phishing content, misleading reports, or other deceitful documents.
  • Security Event and Incident Management: Hackers employ AI to simulate incident scenarios or analyze past events, improving their strategies.

5. 78% of hackers believe that AI will disrupt the way ethical hackers conduct penetration testing or work on bug bounty programs

The landscape of ethical hacking is poised for significant transformation as 78% of hackers anticipate that AI will disrupt traditional methods of conducting penetration testing and participating in bug bounty programs. With the advent of AI-driven tools and technologies, coordinated information operations are expected to become more sophisticated, requiring ethical hackers to adapt to new challenges and methodologies. One of the most profound impacts will be seen in extended detection and response, where AI can provide real-time insights and rapid identification of potential threats. Additionally, behavioral analysis will become a key component, enabling hackers to understand the nuances of how adversarial AI operates and to devise strategies to mitigate potential risks. However, as AI continues to evolve, the ethical hacking community must remain vigilant and ensure they are prepared to address the complexities introduced by adversarial AI tactics.

  • Coordinated information operations will see increased complexity with AI enhancements.
  • Extended detection and response capabilities will benefit from real-time AI insights.
  • Behavioral analysis will be crucial for understanding adversarial AI tactics.
  • There are potential risks associated with AI that ethical hackers need to mitigate.
  • A significant majority of hackers see AI as a disruptive force in ethical hacking and bug bounty programs.